Taylor Barnard, Fortescue Zero and Fusion formula E Team have been at the centre of a paddock storm now for several weeks. It may have reached its peak and zenith at Jarama on Monday when the winner of the last E-Prix last August climbed aboard the new Fusion Porsche and drove out of the pits.
Many were expecting Fortescue Zero, who believe they have a valid contract with the driver, to issue an injunction on Barnard. It didn’t happen. That in itself has raised further questions around the deal now.
The legalities of the matter are ongoing, but for precedents and detail on contracts that this might set in Formula E now, one question is on everyones lips. Does Formula E need an F1 style Contracts Recognition Board (CRB)?
What is a CRB?
The FIA Contract Recognition Board (CRB) is an independent arbitration body established by the FIA to register driver contracts and resolve disputes between Formula 1 teams over competing contracts.
The purpose of it is largely to determine contract validity and priority when teams claim rights to the same driver for the same period, delivering quick rulings without lengthy national court proceedings.
A panel composed derive independent lawyers experienced in contract law from different nationalities. Its origins derive from 1991 following several high-profile contract clashes, notably involving Michael Schumacher’s move from Jordan to Benetton and Jean Alesi’s overlapping deals with Williams/Ferrari/Tyrrell.
It was established under F1’s Concorde Agreement and driver contracts are lodged with the panel board. It has also been referenced for senior technical personnel and the World Rally Championship over the years.

Will FE establish one in FE?
“We discussed it (having a contract recognition board) a few years ago, we touched upon it in FETAMA meetings but that’s more of a question for the FIA if they think it’s necessary,” was Fortescue Zero team principal, Jim Wright’s reflection when asked by Formula E Notebook at Jarama on Wednesday afternoon.
Formula E boss, Jeff Dodds, also cited an ultimate decision coming from the FIA, who are believed to have largely let the two teams in the Barnard-gate case attempt to resolve it out of court.
“I think that that’s a great question for the FIA because obviously that the contract recognition board sits within the FIA within Formula One and it’s within our sport, it’s something that sits within the remit of the FIA.

“Teams are individual businesses, right? So, they’re a business in their own. Every team down there is a business in its own. Whether it’s an OEM or whether it’s an independent customer team, they’re business in their own right.
“There’s clearly a challenge going on between two of those businesses on the grid. We hope it will be resolved shortly because it’s better for us that it gets resolved.
“I’m sure it will be resolved, and I think the learning from this issue or challenge will be greatly discussed by us and the FIA,” concluded Dodds.