Insights from the fast-moving world of Formula E

‘Welcome to the Piranha Club,’ Formula E edition!

‘Welcome to the Piranha Club’.

It is still one of Formula One’s most oft quoted legends. It was attributed to former McLaren boss, Ron Dennis, after Eddie Jordan ended his first season of F1 by having his novice, baby-faced driver, Michael Schumacher, snatched from under his nose by a streetwise Flavio Briatore and Tom Walkinshaw in September 1991.

A quarter of a century on, and Formula E may have just lived through its own razor-toothed predatory moment. Welcome to Barnard-gate.

It’s a story of almost unbelievable chutzpah, on account of the driver, 22 year-old Taylor Barnard and more notably his management, which is managed by Paul Mueller, via his PHM Racing Academy GmbH company, being determined to essentially not recognise its signing to Fortescue Zero last month.

They are believed to be majoring on a narrative that centres upon Barnard being exploited and in their view coerced in to the signing of the deal with Fortescue Zero.

Is it true and accurate? It will probably, and ultimately be for an arbitration court to decide that. But before that comes, the chaos and conjecture flew in the Jarama paddock yesterday.

“They’re laughing at you!”

“They’re laughing at them.”

That was a throwaway line, said to this author by one cheeky rival Team Principal in the Jarama pit lane on Monday morning, just as Taylor Barnard began to climb aboard the Fusion Porsche after a sensational late Sunday night decision to test him, despite his publicly acknowledged signing by Fortescue Zero, three weeks earlier.

That quip related to what, in that individual’s thoughts, was Fusion doing to Fortescue Zero what Benetton had kind of done to Jordan back in ‘91.

In their mind, Fusion was a big fish swallowing a smaller fish (FZ). But in reality, perhaps the opposite was true, because Fortescue Zero – a corporate of significant stature – is in fact the much larger entity from a business point of view as it enters Formula E.

The comment was brutal in nature and designed to be humiliating, but there was some truth in it too. That is because Fusion have seemingly snatched one of Formula E’s prized assets – Taylor Barnard, like he was the proverbial candy, and Fortescue Zero was the inattentive baby.

Photo: Andreas Beil

When I mentioned this quote to a senior management member of Fortescue Zero a few minutes later, there was a wry look, then a swift rebuttal. It felt like there was a kind of delayed shock that this whole situation had been allowed to happen at all.

It is not a surprise to know that Fortescue Zero believe the move is contractually malignant. Vast swathes of the paddock appear to agree, as a pitiful consensus is largely with the Australian team.

However, some are also with Barnard on this, although interestingly very few drivers. ‘He’s just a kid’. ‘He’s been badly advised’ come sme of the opinions.

The general accord is that Fortescue Zero have been done dirty here. Really dirty. A hostile brew of complicated ambition and predatory exploitation has seemingly won out so far, or so the theory goes.

But in fact, this could just be the start of a toxic story that runs and runs, and potentially has a significant effect on a young driver’s career. Will it be for good or ill?

That seems on a knife-edge right now, as Fortescue Zero’s legal team starts to weigh-up its options on how to show its new paddock audience that it is not to be trampled upon.

Photo: Formula E

What it could mean for future precedents on driver’s contracts in motorsport may in fact become deep-rooted should it not be sorted out legally first.

A contract is a legally binding agreement between two or more parties that creates enforceable duties and obligations, but within them there are clauses and get-outs that need mediation sometimes.

The problem comes when aggressive impulses and situations, such as how contracts are conceived and then subsequently broken, specifically occur. That is when conjecture and counter conjecture need legal resolve.

Nuance is not the friend of a contract. That would defeat a contracts object, clearly.

Yet, in the case of Taylor Barnard, such has been the unique circumstances of DS Penske melding in to Fortescue Zero, at a similar time to the birth of Fusion, allied to many other threads of intrigue within this story, that it feels as though it will be not be weeks, but actually month before this whole sorry affair can finally be resolved.

SHARE POST